Lean vs Shredded: 8 Differences (& The Reality)
00:06
Back in 2017, when I was four weeks out from a bodybuilding show, I wrote an article for T-Nation called Lean Versus Shredded: The Cold Hard Truth.
Back in 2017, when I was four weeks out from a bodybuilding show, I wrote an article for T-Nation called Lean Versus Shredded: The Cold Hard Truth.
00:19
In that article, I broke down the eight major differences between being lean and being shredded, what defines each condition, how to transition out of a shredded state, and what it truly takes to get there.
In that article, I broke down the eight major differences between being lean and being shredded, what defines each condition, how to transition out of a shredded state, and what it truly takes to get there.
00:34
At the time, I was crossing the gap between being beach lean and getting truly shredded. I wanted to document the experience honestly, and the article ended up gaining a lot of attention because it explained the reality of what it takes to move from a lean physique to extreme conditioning.
At the time, I was crossing the gap between being beach lean and getting truly shredded. I wanted to document the experience honestly, and the article ended up gaining a lot of attention because it explained the reality of what it takes to move from a lean physique to extreme conditioning.
00:53
In this episode, I want to revisit those lessons and explain the difference between being lean and being shredded.
In this episode, I want to revisit those lessons and explain the difference between being lean and being shredded.
Competition Winner Announcement
01:00
Before we dive in, I want to announce the winner of the anniversary competition.
Before we dive in, I want to announce the winner of the anniversary competition.
01:08
The winner of the £100 personalised supplement stack is Harpinder.
The winner of the £100 personalised supplement stack is Harpinder.
01:20
Congratulations, Harpinder. Please email podcast@rntfitness.com with your shipping address, your current goals, and your supplement routine, and I'll put together a stack specifically for you.
Congratulations, Harpinder. Please email podcast@rntfitness.com with your shipping address, your current goals, and your supplement routine, and I'll put together a stack specifically for you.
Can Everyone Get Shredded?
01:53
The first thing to understand is that almost everyone can get lean.
The first thing to understand is that almost everyone can get lean.
02:01
We've seen thousands of transformations across different ages, backgrounds, and lifestyles.
We've seen thousands of transformations across different ages, backgrounds, and lifestyles.
02:12
However, not everyone can—or should—get shredded.
However, not everyone can—or should—get shredded.
02:18
Getting shredded requires an entirely different level of sacrifice, discipline, focus, and discomfort. It's a very different challenge from simply getting lean.
Getting shredded requires an entirely different level of sacrifice, discipline, focus, and discomfort. It's a very different challenge from simply getting lean.
Defining Lean vs Shredded
What Does "Lean" Mean?
02:36
For men, lean is typically around 7–10% body fat.
For men, lean is typically around 7–10% body fat.
02:54
For women, lean is generally around 15% body fat, depending on individual factors.
For women, lean is generally around 15% body fat, depending on individual factors.
What Does "Shredded" Mean?
03:07
For men, shredded is usually around 4–7% body fat.
For men, shredded is usually around 4–7% body fat.
03:21
For women, getting into truly shredded territory is generally unnecessary unless competing in bodybuilding.
For women, getting into truly shredded territory is generally unnecessary unless competing in bodybuilding.
03:43
The crossover point for men tends to occur around the 6–8% body fat range.
The crossover point for men tends to occur around the 6–8% body fat range.
What Does Shredded Actually Look Like?
04:47
When you become truly shredded, your physique takes on a completely different appearance.
When you become truly shredded, your physique takes on a completely different appearance.
05:02
Your skin becomes paper-thin.
Your skin becomes paper-thin.
05:08
There is almost no visible pinchable body fat.
There is almost no visible pinchable body fat.
05:14
Muscle definition becomes dramatically sharper and more pronounced.
Muscle definition becomes dramatically sharper and more pronounced.
05:21
Bodybuilders often describe this as looking "dry" because the physique appears extremely crisp and detailed.
Bodybuilders often describe this as looking "dry" because the physique appears extremely crisp and detailed.
Do You Ever Need To Be Shredded?
05:43
The honest answer is no.
The honest answer is no.
05:49
Unless you're stepping onto a bodybuilding stage, there is no requirement to get shredded.
Unless you're stepping onto a bodybuilding stage, there is no requirement to get shredded.
06:03
For most people, getting lean provides all the benefits:
For most people, getting lean provides all the benefits:
- Looking great
- Feeling confident
- Maintaining health
- Preserving energy
- Living a normal life
06:23
Most people are far better off aiming for a photoshoot-lean physique rather than pursuing extreme conditioning.
Most people are far better off aiming for a photoshoot-lean physique rather than pursuing extreme conditioning.
The 8 Differences Between Lean and Shredded
1. Some Hunger vs Constant Hunger
07:28
When you're getting lean, you'll occasionally feel hungry.
When you're getting lean, you'll occasionally feel hungry.
07:34
When you're getting shredded, hunger becomes constant.
When you're getting shredded, hunger becomes constant.
07:46
You need to learn to accept hunger as part of the process.
You need to learn to accept hunger as part of the process.
08:03
Meals rarely feel satisfying, and you'll often be thinking about food shortly after eating.
Meals rarely feel satisfying, and you'll often be thinking about food shortly after eating.
08:37
No amount of food volume tricks completely removes the hunger.
No amount of food volume tricks completely removes the hunger.
2. Normal Cravings vs Strange Cravings
08:44
When you're lean, cravings are normal.
When you're lean, cravings are normal.
You might crave:
- Pizza
- Burgers
- Ice cream
08:55
When you're shredded, cravings become bizarre.
When you're shredded, cravings become bizarre.
09:08
You may find yourself fantasising about foods you normally wouldn't care about.
You may find yourself fantasising about foods you normally wouldn't care about.
09:40
You become obsessed with food content, recipes, and unusual food combinations.
You become obsessed with food content, recipes, and unusual food combinations.
3. Happy vs Cranky
10:22
Being lean generally feels fantastic.
Being lean generally feels fantastic.
Benefits include:
- Better mood
- High energy
- Strong performance
- Healthy sex drive
10:36
Being shredded often feels terrible.
Being shredded often feels terrible.
Common experiences include:
- Irritability
- Fatigue
- Low motivation
- Reduced patience
- Poor recovery
11:01
There's an old bodybuilding saying:
There's an old bodybuilding saying:
"The worse you feel, the better you look."
And unfortunately, that's often true.
4. Flexibility vs Precision
11:19
When you're lean, life remains flexible.
When you're lean, life remains flexible.
You can:
- Miss a workout occasionally
- Eat slightly above or below target calories
- Adjust your schedule
11:58
When you're shredded, every detail matters.
When you're shredded, every detail matters.
12:03
Every workout counts.
Every workout counts.
12:06
Every cardio session matters.
Every cardio session matters.
12:10
Food is measured precisely.
Food is measured precisely.
12:13
Mistakes become far less forgiving.
Mistakes become far less forgiving.
5. "Bro Science" Starts Working
13:58
Many bodybuilding techniques seem unnecessary when simply getting lean.
Many bodybuilding techniques seem unnecessary when simply getting lean.
Examples include:
- Fasted cardio
- Carb cut-offs
- Protein-sparing modified fasts (PSMF)
15:22
However, when you're trying to reach extreme levels of leanness, small strategies can sometimes help remove those final stubborn layers of body fat.
However, when you're trying to reach extreme levels of leanness, small strategies can sometimes help remove those final stubborn layers of body fat.
15:39
For most people aiming to get lean, these tactics are unnecessary.
For most people aiming to get lean, these tactics are unnecessary.
6. You Need Muscle
16:13
One of the most important bodybuilding sayings is:
One of the most important bodybuilding sayings is:
"You can't carve a pebble."
16:27
Without a foundation of muscle, getting extremely lean often results in looking skinny rather than athletic.
Without a foundation of muscle, getting extremely lean often results in looking skinny rather than athletic.
16:43
For many people, the journey should be:
For many people, the journey should be:
- Get lean
- Build muscle
- Get leaner later
17:04
Muscle gives a lean physique shape and structure.
Muscle gives a lean physique shape and structure.
7. Mind Games
17:10
The final weeks of getting shredded are often psychological.
The final weeks of getting shredded are often psychological.
17:18
Your mind constantly tries to convince you to:
Your mind constantly tries to convince you to:
- Eat more
- Skip cardio
- Change the plan
- Quit early
17:42
You are effectively battling your own instincts every day.
You are effectively battling your own instincts every day.
17:49
This is where mental toughness becomes essential.
This is where mental toughness becomes essential.
8. Sacrifice
18:00
Getting shredded requires sacrifice.
Getting shredded requires sacrifice.
18:07
The final few weeks often impact:
The final few weeks often impact:
- Social life
- Family time
- Business performance
- Energy levels
- Recovery
18:27
This is why very few people ever reach true contest condition.
This is why very few people ever reach true contest condition.
18:37
The level of commitment required is far beyond what most people are willing—or need—to do.
The level of commitment required is far beyond what most people are willing—or need—to do.
Altered Perception of Reality
18:53
One of the biggest challenges after getting shredded is that your perception of "normal" changes.
One of the biggest challenges after getting shredded is that your perception of "normal" changes.
19:15
Many people begin viewing their stage-ready physique as their new baseline.
Many people begin viewing their stage-ready physique as their new baseline.
19:24
The problem is that shredded is not a healthy long-term condition.
The problem is that shredded is not a healthy long-term condition.
19:40
The real goal should be the sweet spot:
The real goal should be the sweet spot:
- Looking good
- Feeling good
- Performing well
- Having healthy hormones
- Maintaining balance
How To Transition Back From Being Shredded
20:04
The most important rule is simple:
The most important rule is simple:
Have a plan.
20:20
Without a plan, many people swing from extreme dieting into uncontrolled binge eating.
Without a plan, many people swing from extreme dieting into uncontrolled binge eating.
20:52
A structured reverse diet is crucial.
A structured reverse diet is crucial.
This means:
- Gradually increasing calories
- Slowly reducing cardio
- Returning to maintenance over 4–6 weeks
21:08
You also need to stay busy.
You also need to stay busy.
21:16
After months of focus, life can feel empty without a goal.
After months of focus, life can feel empty without a goal.
21:25
Use this time to reconnect with family, friends, and normal life.
Use this time to reconnect with family, friends, and normal life.
My 2014 Binge-Restrict Mistake
22:31
In 2014, I handled this transition terribly.
In 2014, I handled this transition terribly.
22:49
During contest prep, I became completely obsessed with food.
During contest prep, I became completely obsessed with food.
23:12
The moment the competition ended, I swung straight into binge eating.
The moment the competition ended, I swung straight into binge eating.
23:24
The obsession didn't disappear—it simply changed form.
The obsession didn't disappear—it simply changed form.
23:40
I realised the problem wasn't dieting itself.
I realised the problem wasn't dieting itself.
23:43
The problem was oscillating between extremes.
The problem was oscillating between extremes.
How To Break The Cycle
26:09
1. Stop Extreme Dieting
26:14
You don't need a massive calorie deficit.
You don't need a massive calorie deficit.
A moderate deficit works extremely well.
2. Stop Deprivation
26:48
Binge eating is often a predictable response to prolonged restriction.
Binge eating is often a predictable response to prolonged restriction.
3. Eat Consistently
26:58
Monday should look similar to Saturday.
Monday should look similar to Saturday.
Consistency removes the mental chaos.
4. Let Go of Punishment
27:20
You don't need to "earn" food.
You don't need to "earn" food.
You don't need to punish yourself with extra cardio.
27:33
That mindset keeps the cycle alive.
That mindset keeps the cycle alive.
Final Thoughts
27:48
The lessons from getting shredded eventually helped create the RNT Fitness Five Phase Methodology.
The lessons from getting shredded eventually helped create the RNT Fitness Five Phase Methodology.
28:02
The biggest lesson I learned was that sustainable success comes from structure, consistency, and balance—not extremes.
The biggest lesson I learned was that sustainable success comes from structure, consistency, and balance—not extremes.
28:18
Over time, moving away from obsession allowed me to live in what I call the sweet spot: lean, healthy, strong, and sustainable.
Over time, moving away from obsession allowed me to live in what I call the sweet spot: lean, healthy, strong, and sustainable.
28:38
Thanks for listening, and I'll see you in the next episode.
Thanks for listening, and I'll see you in the next episode.
👉 Next Steps:
- Book a 1-1 strategy session with my team to find out more: https://www.rntfitness.com/applynow
- Find out if you’re ready for a transformation at https://www.rntfitness.com/transform
.jpg)
.png)
